Random, day-to-day reflections of what it means to live as a member of the human race on a planet which has become as vulnerable as a human body.
Cecile Pineda's books are available from Independent Publishers Group.
The original Cambridge Analytica (CA) research article done by Roger missed a critical CBS story and interview the day after the Guardian story came out.
This missed news story would suggest that the impacts of the role of CA's tactics on the election didn't play as great a role as the article states. However, this doesn't mean that the use of psychographic profiling during elections or the broader impacts of our broken electoral system have gone away, or worse, are being ignored by the msm.
*****
“We ‘broke’ Facebook,” and swung the Brexit vote — Chris Wylie And did it on behalf of Robert Mercer and Steve Bannon.
The
piece has extensive links to content meant to enhance this article. Its
an attempt to broaden the discussion about privacy and our badly broken
electoral system.
The 3–17–18 rehash of the Cambridge Analytica story by The Guardian’s Observer Magazine and the New York Times
may have finally set off a dramatic chain reaction that could reshape
this country’s electoral and media institutions like no other.
A
Canadian PhD (Chris Wylie) and Steve Bannon came together to form
Cambridge Analytica with funding from Robert Mercer allowing it to
obtain the raw data from 50 million Facebook users from Professor
Aleksandr Kogan of Cambridge University, and distill the list down to 17
million candidates, using computer driven psychological profiling that
micro-targeted them with ads either to switch their vote to Trump or not
vote at all. There was an immediate skeptical response from the left
that there is no proof that profiling tactics actually worked. One
author even bought Bannon’s claim that the database wasn’t used (here is politifacts response). There have been calls for Facebook to contact those affected — or investigate to see if they were impacted.
How many people even remember that Facebook was caught just a few years ago with their phone app that allowed them to record your conversations? Or even more dramatic that by 2014 Facebook had already been conducting experiments on its users on how to manipulate users mood, even going so far as to openly claim
that Facebook would become one of the most powerful political election
tools ever. And lest we not forget, the Trump campaign gave Facebook $70
million during the final weeks of the 2016 election with Facebook’s
employees actually embedding at Trump’s digital headquarters set up by
Jared Kushner.
The first decent alternative media piece on the scale of the Cambridge Analytica (CA) hack and Facebook’s involvement was written by Roberto J. González
at Counterpunch. Facebook’s model of selling people’s personal
information to advertisers is only the tip of the iceberg on this as
there can be no doubt that they are also giving it to government
agencies. Many more have since followed for example:
Buried in the original Guardian piece by Carole Cadwalladr
was Chris Wylie’s explicit details about the scandal that exposes CA’s
public claims as lies that led to their CEO being fired within days. It
laid out the even more explosive details about the SCL Group
(the UK military cyber warfare group and connections that CA was based
on) and how two Cambridge University psychologists (Kosinski &
Stillwell) designed the Facebook quiz that could be used to quantify
five personality traits — Openness, Conscientiousness, Extroversion,
Agreeableness and Neuroticism that could be used to build personalized
ads, attacking an estimated 17 million voters the same way that Reagan
and the Stanford Research Institute came up with strategies to split off
union workers in 1980 but in a much more targeted way (see below for
more background on this.
But then Mathew Hindman was able to interview Aleksandr Kogan,
the Cambridge professor who gave Cambridge Analytica the massive
database he’d taken with Facebook’s permission. He gave Hindman details
on how the data mining (psychographic profiling) worked and how good it
was in identifying party affiliation or the individuals personal
psychology. For a bit of mind bend, go google psychographic profiling or
read this article that includes below CA profile data sheet.
CA Personal Profile spreadsheet from 5–18–17 Quartz Article
As demonstrated by this story on gerrymandering,
the republican agenda of profiling Americans is far more about voter
suppression than about getting the target to switch preferences — so
Trump’s ongoing attack meme “Crooked Hillary” would be reinforced many
times over when FBI director Comey’s announced their investigation the
week before the election that resulted in nearly a 10 point drop in
support for Clinton. That drop was further exacerbated with publication
of the Wikileaks story describing how Clinton had taken control of the
Democratic National Committee in order to torpedo Bernie Sander’s
campaign. Even so, Sanders received over 40% of democratic primary
votes — so why would the “Crooked Hillary” meme work? This was America’s
dirty political system at work — not “the Russians.”
The Broader View — Our Rigged Electoral Process
This
story isn’t just about how the U.S. came to elect a billionaire
egomaniac as president, but how our electoral system has been destroyed
by America’s elites. It all started with the 1971 Powell memo, moved into second gear during the Reagan era that included the formation of Rupert Murdoch’s Fox News Network.
It picked up speed with the theft of the 2000 election that was quickly
followed by 9/11, and has now jumped into high gear. It took Adam
Curtis’ Century of the Self BBC documentary
(that has never been shown by any major U.S. media outlet) to present
the historic role of the corporate media’s use of subversive public
relations tactics to poison our electoral system, not to mention
creating a consumer hell. The video lays out the evolution of public
relations from the days of Edward Bernays and Walter Lippmann (who coined the concept of stereotypes and the role of journalism and an enlightened public) and documents how the Stanford Research Institute
used computer generated databases and psychographic profiling of
self-centered baby boomer behavior to identify Reagan democrats in the
1980 presidential election. It has not stopped since then — even Obama had his big data voter machine.
Like
any two bit magician (anyone remember the Wizard of Oz?) the corporate
media has self censored its own domination of our electoral system and
in turn is desperately trying to distract us with Russiagate. From the
historic role of voter suppression of all kinds (Jim Crow, Political PACs, Gerrymandering, work day voting, negative attack strategies etc.) to Citizen’s United
or the outright theft by the Supreme Court in 2000, the biggest scandal
of all is how the corporate media refuses to address its own role in
shaping this country’s two party fiasco. Back during the McCain Feingold
debates on electoral reform that was broadcast by C-Span, a
representative stood up and said that nothing will change as long as the
media which is the biggest opponent of campaign financial reform (its
biggest profits come during the presidential horse races) controls the
arena the game is played in. Google and Facebook know this as they are
shooting to take over as the delivery vehicle for that big pot of money
but does the American voter have even the slightest clue?
Predictions
suggest that over 50% of political finance money will go to social
media companies like Facebook by 2020. During the 2016 election, the
media was openly claiming that their news coverage of Trump’s behavior
was worth over $5 billion. They even had their own October surprise as another in a long history of such moves for Trump with the Access Hollywood Tapes
but then we had the Wikileaks and Comey investigation of Clinton that
was the main reason (voter suppression) for people not voting for
Crooked Hillary (Trump’s winning meme).
Nearly 40% of eligible voters stayed home — a figure that has remained
at this level or below it for over a century, yet there has been no
attempt to resolve the problem institutionally (imagine if the public
school system ignored the fact that 40% of the country’s kids weren’t
showing up for school).
But the story doesn’t end with its
impact to our electoral institution but also drills into the heart of
the growing fourth amendment crisis around privacy and how nearly an
entire country has been brainwashed into thinking that they have nothing
to hide by letting Facebook collect and sell what we do online.
Apologies, but our privacy as well as the right to bare arms were
originally enshrined because of rogue behavior by the British government
and its chartered corporation, the East India Trading Company. When it
comes to privacy, the dark side as exposed by Wikileaks and Snowden is
willing to both kill opponents and undermine legitimate civil ones and
hide the fact it is going ahead with deploying computer algorithms in military applications, prison systems, jobs and what Google and Facebook think we should read or not read that is pushing us into a negative form of tribalism.
The hackers that could breach our private data on Facebook and other
sites and steal our it are no longer just a bunch of punks but
governments both here and around the world.
NSA Political Cyber warfare Plan — Ed Snowden release
If
the MSM truly wanted to educate the public about the historic evidence
of vote tampering in a true and honest way, it would have to start with
this country’s long standing interference in other country’s elections
or at least start to tabulate some of the other, more egregious examples
of foreign interference. For example back in the months just prior to
Obama’s election foreign nationals from India
flooded democratic representatives across the U.S. in an aggressive
campaign to remove the US ban on India over its nuclear weapons program.
Those bribes worked and democrats caved in to the republican strategy.
The ongoing Russiagate (Bill Moyer’s Timeline)
campaign by part of the liberal media is a desperate attempt to remove
Trump and for that reason alone is a worthy project if it actually ousts
him, but also because it keeps a spotlight on our electoral
system — where it should be the job of the alternative press to fill in
the missing narratives — items this piece barely brings into play.
During
the 2008 presidential election, the Obama campaign hoodwinked the
progressive left with its own unique play on identity politics. But from
the day he excommunicated Rev. Wright up until his chief staff Rahm
Emanuel pulled the plug on the massive blog that had millions of users
who had been promised a direct line of input to the Obama
administration, an immense hole in the future of social media was ripped
open almost before it ever got off ground. Major sites like Newsvine
(that was bought by MSNBC and then shut down) had immense numbers of
democratic activists that were able to shoot down the criminal tactics
of republicans almost on a daily basis, resulting in a far different way
to stop the traditional dirty tricks the right wing has long been known
for. The star chamber tactics at Newsvine against the left,
environmentalists and union organizers was a sobering example of the
DNC’s own dirty politics.
The Cambridge Analytica scandal is
an important symbolic event that should be taken seriously on its
face — as it represents the growing power of social media and the loss
of privacy that our society should have never have been forced to opt
into. And last but not least, during the last budget bill, the media
completely buried the importance of an attached rider called the CLOUD Act.
This act is even worse than the Patriot Act because it is designed to
get around government spying laws by allowing foreign allies to do the
dirty work our own laws block them from doing.
What can be done?
Consider closing your Facebook account down — or strip it of all your personal information.
Move toward “meaningful transparency” by ensuring that users “have access to and control over their data”;
Protect
users’ personal information by providing “end-to-end encryption” that
would prevent corporate and government surveillance;
Cease collecting and storing data that “isn’t necessary for your product or business”;
Provide
equal protections to all communities and stop collecting “information
that is vulnerable to misuse,” like immigration status and political
views; and
Support
“laws that require a warrant before the government can demand
information about your users” and “reforms that curtail mass
surveillance.”
3.
Don’t use Facebook for political organizing — let representatives from
formal groups do the organizing — go elsewhere that promises not to
track your political activity
6. Support public ownership of internet service providers that agree to do opt out vs. opt in data collection
7. Demand that all social media sites have an opt out policy and that they never sell or release your data
8. Tell your friends about the Cloud Act and demand its removal.
9. Learn how to delete your browser cookies on a regular basis — leave cookies in place for sites that have passwords.
10. Support digital rights groups like Electronic Frontiers Foundation.
11.
Don’t rely on any one search engine (google — Yahoo or Bing) for
searches. Note that all of them inject tracking services every time you
do a search. Duck Duck Go is an alternative search Engine.
12.
Post a statement up on Facebook that you don’t want your data sold to
anyone. Many people don’t watch commercial TV because they are acutely
aware of that model’s design to sell you as product to advertisers. The
same goes for Facebook and any site that has fallen into the Google and
hundreds of other tracking companies — the above privacy badger can be
used to shut down the most invasive of them.
13.
If you do any kind of activist work — please learn the ropes about
Virtual Private Networks (VPN)’s and that you will need to bypass the 5–9–14 spy networks to be serious.
14. Make sure you use strong passwords and be careful of password managers as hackers are learning how to break into them.
The Nature Conservancy pointed out hat under the new budget, the line item supporting the Land and Water Conservation Fund and other conservation wins total an increase of $25 million.
Her husband’s to Aleppo gone, master of the “Tiger:”
Though his bark cannot
be lost,
Yet it shall be
tempest-tost.
Macbeth, Act I, Scene III
News of the week in Review: With the twitterization of
Secretary of State, Rex Tillerson, the administration advanced two new
nominations, and one appointment: Mike Pompeo, close buddy ofthe Kochs, and torture architect, as the new
Secretary of State, Gina
Haspel, George Bush’s torture
queen, to head
the CIA, and out-of-control war hawk, John
Bolton’s appointment as National Security Adviser, displacing Gen.
McMaster. Wrote Abigail Tracy in Vanity Fair “It’s
the perfect storm.”
Hell Hole Syria, killing ground of proxy war
These nominations must be unconditionally opposed. If any doubt
remains as to where this administration is headed, this trifecta witches' brew leaves
no doubt. In that light, every one of the world’s hot spots, places like Yemen, Iraq,
and Syria, and
eventually Iran, can expect to get lots hotter. You can bet—if we learned anything from the "sudden" invasion of Afghanistan, the Pentagon has a sheaf of war plans on the drawing board ready to go: Korea? check. Iran? check. Russia? check. China? check. To help stir up the brew, Cambridge Analytica, the social
engineering media company, has apparently received millions of dollars to
militarize the minds of Americans. According
to Chris Hedges, our political landscape now sees the naked erection of an
iron wall in such areas as social media, just one example of the incremental
changes that threaten to silence everyone. The cause du jour this week is “March
for Our Lives.” Whose lives? Black lives? How about the lives of all the kids
the U.S. wantonly kills in Yemen, Pakistan, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, and
wherever it lands its drones? How about a manifesto against the killing of the
world’s kids?This is a connection that
needs to be made now. Not next year.
The good news this week includes the filing by the ACLU of a
lawsuit naming ICE for cruel and unusual punishment.The bad news has it that the lawsuit was
filed after U.S.
immigration authorities separated a Congolese mother and her six-year-old
daughter who came to the U.S. seeking asylum.
After four days in detention, authorities abruptly took her
daughter way and flew her 2,000 miles away (remember, our taxes pay for air
fare) to a shelter for unaccompanied minors in Chicago. The woman, Mrs. L.,
could hear the child screaming in the next room. The child turned seven during
the four months she was held without her mother.
Under pressure from the ACLU lawsuit, ICE released Ms. L,
giving her only a few hours notice before sending her into the detention center
parking lot with a plastic bag containing her few belongings and nowhere to go.
“A Berlin police officer was a friend and, risking his own
life, would call them and want them of any planned Gestapo raids. We owe our
lives to this man. I see parallels in today’s America. ICE is instilling fear
in the immigrant community, going after otherwise law-abiding, hard-working
people whose only crime is wanting a better life. [By alerting Oakland
residents of the coming ICE raids, Schaaf] has shown the same moral fiber and
courage as the Berlin police officer.”
And Daily
Kos reported that on Thursday ICE was fixing to deport David Chavez-Macias
who suffers froman incurable heart
condition, which amounts to a death sentence (not for ICE, for the deportee,
unfortunately.) And weekly planeloads land in San Salvador carrying 460 Salvadoreans
many of them given TPS temporary status from the civil war, who have been
forced by ICE to return to El Salvador.
David Chavez-Macias and his wife
The question to us is: in Hitler’s Germany, would we have
acted like “good Germans.” or would we have stood aside? The way we act now
provides the answer.
Find either a detention center near
you, or ICE headquarters near you. Create a presence there, even if you start
out alone. Get folks to join you. Smack pots and pans.
Berkeley, CA residents: e-mail your
council members at council@cityofberkeeley.info demanding they vote for the ballot measure “Berkeley
Community United for Police Oversight.”
This week we run the fourth and last section of the La
Bloga’s 2010 article:
Jean Blum: Finger in
Goliath’s Eye - Part IV
published in La Bloga, May 9. 2010
Corrections Corporation
of America’s shares have split twice, multiplied ten-fold. Net profits listed
in 2005 of $23.4 million ballooned to $67 the first six months of 2009,
representing the largest market share of privately run facilities. Its
stockholders number government officials including Dick Cheney, who at last
count held stock valued at $85 million.
A sputtering audit
As far back as 2001, complaints from immigrant detention facilities nationwide
started to flood the Department of Homeland Security’s inboxes. In response DHS
ordered an audit. Although the list of targeted facilities initially stood at
18, after a long delay it was reduced to only five. The Passaic County Jail
under the authority of Sheriff Jerry Speziale was notorious enough to make the
final cut. In 2005 ninety-four PCJ detainees turned in complaint sheets
indicating alleged areas of mistreatment and abuse. Of these 19 declined to be
interviewed. Conceivably the OIG’s unwillingness to allow them to talk with a
lawyer present may have led to some reluctance. Of the remaining 75, the OIG
cherry-picked 32.
But the arrival of what were largely inexperienced auditors in June of 2005 led
to mounting recriminations on Sheriff Speziale’s part so that by July 2005 he
had ordered them out of “his” jail on charges of “arrogance.” Summoned to
Washington in August, presumably for a reprimand, Speziale returned undaunted,
having managed to finesse a new federal contract allowing Passaic County to
substitute U.S. Marshall prisoners for immigrant detainees. At the same rate of
$77 a day per prisoner “bed,” the Passaic County General Fund would get hardly
any time to suffer. The auditors were reinstated in August, and by December the
detainees had begun to be removed to other facilities, but an official report
from DHS had to wait until November of 2006 when the initial shock of Abu
Ghraib had died down.
Shortly after the report’s publication an internal e-mail dated January 19,
2007 by a reporter from the North Jersey News Group queried the DHS: “several
former Passaic detainees have called me and said that they told the auditors
about abuse, beatings, withholding of food, etc. by jail staffers, but felt
those claims weren’t reflected in the final audit.” Tamara Faulkner of the DHS
replied: “We could not develop sufficient evidence to substantiate the
credibility of these cases….For example one detainee stated that he was beaten
by the correctional officers and slammed to the floor. We could not find
documentary evidence such as medical reports, incident reports, or physical
evidence to substantiate the allegation….”
Blum was not surprised by the DHS’s watered down report. As far back as June,
2005 she had received a letter from detainee Roddy Sanchez stating: “On June 8,
2005 immigration officers from Washington D.C. came to see us….I thought
they’re going to stop by and listen to our complaints; instead they said they
were coming [back] and they never did.”
Blum points out that, far from ending any abuses, shipping the detainees from
Passaic to other more distant facilities, some in retaliation for having filed
their complaints with the Office of the Inspector General in the first place,
occasioned more travel inconvenience for their families and lawyers who needed
to visit. It caused Blum to have to curtail her activism because she could no
longer afford the detainees’ collect long-distance calls on her retiree’s
income, nor could she be as effective with administrators with whom she had not
had reason to develop open channels of communication. And it did not put an end
to abuses at Passaic County Jail where in 2006 the use of dogs was shortly
re-introduced.
The business of detention is business
“When you take to activism, you need to know what you are doing,” states Blum.
“At the time I joined it, the New Jersey Civil Rights Defense Committee was
calling for the release of all immigrants held in administrative detention, but
I realized that nothing of the sort was going to happen any time soon…. At $77
dollars a day, nobody gives up that kind of money.”
All detention facilities, public and private, enter into a contractual
agreement with the Department of Homeland Security/ICE to house detainees. It
is in their interest to obtain the most favorable rate per diem and to keep
their overhead low. This they accomplish by overcrowding, by providing
inadequate diet and poor-to-nonexistent medical attention and by keeping staff
salaries and training to a minimum, resulting in the kinds of prison abuse both
verbal and physical, documented earlier. In 2003, at $28,000 per inmate/year
plus a 10% commissary markup, housing detainees brought in $12 million to the
Passaic County Jail, which according to the sheriff’s department spokesperson
passed directly into the county general fund.
County and Federally run jails are now in competition with privately run
facilities, of which the numbers rose from 5 in 1990 to over 200 by 2000, But
if evidence serves, compared to publicly run facilities, privately operated
facilities such as those run by Corrections Corporation of America (with 63
facilities in 19 states) compete to bring their overhead even lower. To secure
a profitable bottom line, C.C.A lobbies a compliant congress for stricter
detention rules; it secures its interests through the use of interlocking
directorates, political contributions, and expensive lobbying; to head key
projects, it hires retired government administrators and military personnel to
guarantee results.
Although it will soon be converted to house only female detainees, C.C.A.’s T.
Don Hutto facility in Texas, initially billed as “America’s family residence,”
housed women, (some of them pregnant), children and infants in Kevlar tents,
and required them to wear prison uniform (even the children). Inmates brought
in up to $200 per inmate/day. The chaplain (who doubles as spokesman for
C.C.A.’s Houston Processing Center) stated, “we’re here to take care of the
product they deliver to us. Until they’re deported we take care of the
detainees as best we can.”
In a 2008 conference call to investors, from company headquarters in Tennessee,
Chief Operations Officer John D. Ferguson got specific about what that care
might be. “The intent now is to detain everyone that’s apprehended at the
border and charge them initially with something called ‘entry without
inspection.’ That will be a misdemeanor, requiring somewhere between 15 and 30
days of detention. So then persons with [a] deportation [order] or minimum
conviction, which means someone who…committed [a] misdemeanor, will face a
felony charge, which could lead to six months to two years of detention or
incarceration.” Enthused by the President’s fiscal 2009 budget, he stated, “We
see that the budget supports the detention population of 33,000 inmate detainee
beds—that’s up from 27,500 the previous year and quite above what the…original
budget was. What I am most encouraged about is everything we are hearing says
33,000 is still not enough.”
In keeping with the New World Order, the manipulation of language to serve
unconstitutional ends is also reflected in the directives of the office of
Detention and Removal (DRO), a sub-agency of ICE, which calls its ten-year plan
“Endgame,” an eerie echo of “Final Solution,” the term referring to
extermination preferred by the Nazi Third Reich. Its goal is removal of all
removable aliens by 2012, including 590,000 persons ignoring deportation
orders, and 630,000 “criminal” aliens (most of them broken tail light and
‘entry without inspection’ folks), a total of 1,220,000 souls. And John D.
Ferguson’s low-end projections notwithstanding, according to Marjorie Meyers,
chief federal defender of South Texas, people convicted of illegal re-entry are
actually receiving anywhere from four to eight years in jail. “As a result they
are pushing undocumented people deeper and deeper underground so they are more
exploitable,” according to Lisa Brody, a San Benito Texas attorney.
Since 2001, Corrections Corporation of America’s shares have split twice,
multiplied ten-fold, closing recently at $24.28. Net profits listed in 2005
annual report of $23.4 million ballooned to $67 million in the first six months
of 2009, representing the largest market share of privately run facilities. Its
stockholders number government officials including Dick Cheney who at last
count held stock valued at $85 million. Although Corrections Corporation of
America ranks first in the percentage of detainee deaths of any public or privately
run operator, last available records indicate that CEO Ferguson took home $3
million in 2007 executive compensation.
Holding detainees is not only profitable to government and privately run jails,
but it also serves other corporate interests as well. Standing to benefit are
telephone companies (prison telephone cards cost $10 for the first 5 minutes);
weapons manufacturers, transport and healthcare companies, and food service
firms, even hi-tech concerns. Obviating the passé need for tattooed numbers on
prisoner forearms, promotional copy for one such corporation reads, “The Quetel
Corporation hopes for vigorous sales of its new system to bar code prisoners
and equip guards with monitoring scanners.”
In the face of ICE’s operation “Return to Sender” increasing the arrest quota
for its fugitive teams from 125 in 2003 to 1,000 in 2009 Jenni Gainsborough of
the ACLU’s National Prison Project states the obvious: “[There is a] basic
philosophical problem when you begin turning over administration of prisons to
people who have an interest in keeping people locked up.”
Not the change we've waited for
Detainee retention policies are in urgent need of review but as recently as
August, 2009, the Obama administration declared that it would have to wait
until 2010 to overhaul any immigration laws put in place during the Bush years
other than shifting some of its emphasis to holding employers responsible for
hiring illegal workers. But a recent federal investigation of American Apparel,
a Los Angeles clothing manufacturer, which turned up certain irregularities in
the identity documents provided by some workers resulted in the firing of 1,800
people, presumably driving them deeper into the underground economy.
According to a New York Times editorial of October 1, John Morton, the director
of Immigration & Customs Enforcement, is quoted calling it “a milestone in
the fight against illegal immigration.” “But,” questions the Times, “one has to
ask who benefits from a crackdown like this….A crackdown that forces 1,800 taxpaying
would-be Americans into joblessness in a dismal economy is a law enforcement
victory only in the bitterest, narrowest sense. As a solution to the problem of
unauthorized workers—1,800 down, millions to go—it’s ludicrous.”
In October, 2009, DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano announced that plans were
underway to “improve” the immigrant detention system. The department proposed
to consolidate detainees in facilities where conditions would more
appropriately reflect their status as non-criminals; it would provide reliable
medical care for them, and it would set up a system of more centralized
oversight. Still lacking in this proposal, however, are any provisions for
enforceable standards governing due process oversight to insure people are no
longer detained without cause, especially over protracted periods of time.
Lacking as well is any commitment to developing alternatives to detention,
particularly for those with families. And no provision is made for oversight of
immigration law enforcement by local police through the 287(g) program (which
deputizes state and local law enforcement agents to catch illegal immigrants),
and the “Criminal Alien” laws which allow local police to collaborate with ICE
agents in the harassment of innocent people by such practices as workplace
raids, racial profiling and midnight home raids such as those recently
occurring in East Hampton, N.Y., in clear violation of the Fourth Amendment.
Jean Blum
For Jean Blum, retiree living on a fixed income, during the many months she
worked tirelessly to aid detainees, despite the pressure, there must have been
something driving her to play David to such a colossal Goliath. “You have phone
calls coming day and night. Once the detainees had been moved, I still got
calls from Bergen Country or Monmouth County—collect charges I could no longer
afford. The authorities [at Monmouth and Bergen] were too far away for me to
advocate effectively any longer. Eventually you burn out. But I am very much
aware of the issues involving people who are displaced. I could not turn my
back because that is my own history as a Holocaust survivor but love has little
to do with it,” she says. “I am not conscious of harboring feelings of love.”
Asked to comment about Napolitano’s recently proposed reforms, she is
uncompromising. “Comment? Are you kidding? Throw all the bums out and start
over again? Except there are no different bums to take over the reins! Things
were better under [the Bush administration]. Lawlessness was the order of the
day and there was no doubt about that. After [Bush] the deluge is where we are
now.”
Common Dreams: Eleven mayors applauded for refusing to do
business with any companies not supporting net neutrality.
One of my readers recently remarked that, by addressing themes of immigration, and
immigrant detention and deportation, this newsletter
seemed to be wandering off topic.I
hereby remind readers that the issue continues and will always be personal to
me: much of my childhood misery originates from my Mexican father’s
undocumented status.In the years before
my birth, the U. S. suffered one of its periodic attacks of xenophobia,
deporting up to 2,000,000 Mexicans. My father had every good reason to live in
fear—despite his many advanced degrees, despite his exceptional linguistic
abilities. But more centrally, the overarching topic is and always has been the total oppression which subsumes all other issues, and to which all other issues are related.
Late January, ICE amused themselves deporting Joel Colindres
despite his valid marriage, his approved I-130 visa, no criminal record, the
two children he leaves behind—and his still-pending casepleading for asylum in the 5th
district court. And today Truthout reports that when undocumented families are
detained, they are now being split up. Parents
are being detained separately from their children, often miles away. The Daily Kos reported that fear of mass deportations is
keeping families away from food distribution centers, and children from
attending school with access to free school lunch programs. Hunger in America?
The richest country in the world?
Black humor has it that to fund the Pentagon giveaway, and the new tax scam, the government
is expected to announce that ICE will start deporting seniors instead of people
of color to lower social security and medicare costs. Older people are easier
to catch and won’t remember how to get back home.
Deportation news this week also includes the story of a young
19-year-old man, shot to death by S.F. finest at 21st and Capp Streets,
San Francisco. His last cry was: “I don’t want to be deported.” No one
does—that is, not until indefinite detention in immigration jail becomes so
utterly dehumanizing and intolerable, people are reduced to begging for relief.
What does intolerable consist in? Needing to urinate and defecate in plastic
bags because no jailers are available to let a detainee out of his/her cell to use
the one common bathroom.
How long would we tolerate such conditions without either
crying “uncle” or going stark raving?
Reverend Deborah Lee at the Interfaith Movement for Human Dignity,
who is organizing vigils outside the Richmond California West County Detention
Center, had this to say: “We can’t just watch the immigration policy of this
country play itself out and do nothing while ICE and the Border Patrol hunt
people down and tear families apart. The administration talks about our efforts
to protect people and fight this…system as though this was just a state or a
city passing a law to defy their enforcement efforts….These laws exist because
our community is making a moral commitment and acting on it….Sanctuary isn’t
just a law: it’s our community defending people in danger.”
This week, we run Part III of my 2009 article, originally
published by La Bloga, Finger in Goliath’s Eye, based on my ten- day-long
interview of Jean Blum, a Holocaust survivor, and volunteer in the detention the
Patterson N.J. and Monmouth County jails, in which she blows the whistle on the
first reported “disappearance” of an immigrant held in deportation detention,
Tanveer Ahmad. “The difficulty of confirming [Tanveer]
Ahmad’s very existence showed that death could fall between the cracks in
immigration detention, the hundreds of county jails, for-profit prisons and
federal detention centers where more than 400,000 people a year are held while
the government tries to deport them.”
Jean Blum: Finger in
Goliath’s Eye - Part III
"Therefore with
all humbleness I am seeking your compassion by asking you please, your Honor,
allow me a visit with my children. Please, your Honor, I don’t want to abandon
my children due to circumstances beyond my control. I am asking you please to
grant me one favor to say goodbye and don’t take my motherly rights away from
me.” . . . Juliette Tucker was ordered deported without being allowed to see
her children.
"DHS/ICE is breaking our families apart”
In immigrant detention, scant attention is paid to “family values.”
A summary of grievances by detainees at Monmouth County [NJ] Jail dated January
16, 2006 contains the following: “Over 95% of the detainees here are New York
based…. All of our families [reside] in New York. DHS/ICE…never in their minds,
have they ever taken the hardship for our families to travel over “3 HOURS”
(round trip) to see us. What is even [worse] is that the visit is only “15
MINUTES.”
And behind bulletproof glass, furthermore, a lot of the detainees are getting
deported without being able to even hug or kiss our parents, kids, wife,
etc...! [They] are being deported on a daily basis, on an unknown date.
[Fifteen] minutes just for them to say “goodbye” seems really bad! It is just
extreme hardship for our families to travel so far for 15 minutes only. DHS/ICE
is breaking our families apart before they even try to deport us!”
Roddy Sanchez in a letter to Blum dated June 11, 2005 states: “A lot of times
when night falls, I cry because I have a newborn daughter. I got my whole
family out here, but when you go in front of the judge they tell you, take your
family back to your country, or the judge will say they can always go on
welfare….” But the dreams and hopes of most detainees with families do not
include taking them back with them to their country of origin, and in many
instances, family members are legitimate citizens of the United States.”
Quoted in the NJCRDC’s Voices, in May of 2004 a Sierra Leone
journalist in Hudson County Jail writes: “In the event of my deportation, I am
afraid that my fiancé and two kids will suffer tremendously, because they
depend on me for everything. Who will provide shelter for them? Who will be
their role model? Who will be concerned about them going to college? Who will
feed them?”
But the display by the presiding authorities of Passaic County Jail of the
kinds of casual cruelty that ripped families apart is perhaps best exemplified
by two accounts cited here. Although detainees held in “administrative detention,”
and not classified as criminals, their treatment is comparable to that of
ordinary prisoners. Joseph Elchin’s letter addressed to Blum of June, 2005
states that, despite the repeated pleas of his sister, and the initiatives on
his behalf by the public defender, he was not allowed to speak to his sister
who wished to notify him that his mother was dying and had been rushed to the
hospital to be placed on a ventilator. “As a matter of fact, no one from this
institution ever informed me of anything. I [only] learned of the situation
when I called home Monday evening.”
The Passaic County Sheriff’s department and the jail warden refused him the
privilege of visiting his mother on her deathbed before she was removed from
the ventilator. “Judge Guzman had denied such bedside visit stating that ‘if I
wanted to pay my last respects I could do so at the funeral.’” But in fact,
arrangements for him to attend his mother’s funeral were denied when, despite
intercession by his sister and the Public Defender, “Judge Guzman refused to
sign the order.”
The Eichin case, a criminal one, can be compared to a similar case, this one
affecting an immigrant detainee. In a letter dated Sept. 26, 2005 addressed to
Judge Patricia E. Henry, Juliette Tucker, who is about to be deported to
Jamaica writes: “I have been in the United States for eight years and have
never had any criminal involvement. As you know I have three beautiful children
who need their mother. …I am pleading not so much for myself, but for my
children. …Please take this plea into consideration by allowing me to take all
three children with me to Jamaica….My plan is to go to Jamaica first and
shortly after I send for my children….Due to this, your Honor, I will truly
like to see my children before I leave on the 24 October, 2005. Therefore with
all humbleness I am seeking your compassion by asking you please, your Honor,
allow me a visit with my children. Please, your Honor, I don’t want to abandon
my children due to my circumstances beyond my control. I am asking you please to grant me one favor to say goodbye and don’t
take my motherly rights away from me.” And although Jean Blum tried to
effect an intervention on her behalf, Juliette Tucker was ordered deported
without being allowed to see her children.
Deportees are expelled with little more
than the shirts on their backs. “Basically they are sent back to a country, not
even necessarily their own,” Blum explains. “They arrive at the airport of the
receiving country with no resources and no means to contact their families.”
In a letter addressed to her from Kingston Jamaica dated August 2, 2005,
detainee Barry Walker writes: “When they gave me the flight paper on Friday
July 29, they took me straight to the airport with no notice to get any clothes
or money together. Somehow I made it home here to my family and I am just
breathing a bit of freedom….Because you are a person among people, I know faith
will bring us together again one day.”
Prison abuse, physical and verbal, inadequate diet, medical neglect, casual
cruelty and disregard of their civil and human rights discourage prisoners from
fighting their deportation orders. “Many eventually give up the struggle,” says
Blum, “but these may be considered the lucky ones.” Some—no one knows exactly
how many—never get the chance to make that despairing choice.
The dead, the disappeared
Still unverified is another kind of Homeland Security list. In his affidavit of
December 12, 2005, on behalf of his client’s imminent deportation to Syria,
Shayana Kadidal cites the case of one ‘Abd al-Rahman al-Musa deported from the
United States to Syria in January 2005 and who “has not been heard from since.”
He includes mention of one Nabil al-Marabh, also deported to Syria in 2004 who
has “not been heard from again. Amnesty sources indicate that he has been imprisoned and has been tortured.”
Although as early as 2007 the New York Times had begun drawing
attention to immigrant deaths in detention, it was not until April 3, 2009 that
it was able to publish an account describing how, in September of 2005 Jean
Blum had received a letter addressed to the NJCRDC and copied to ALAFFA
reporting the death of one “Ahmed Tender.” Written in broken English,
nonetheless the message was clear enough: “Today one of the INS immigration
die….No emergency, and the jail very very [careless] about INS detainees. Mr.
Ahmed complain about chest pain. Before he die was saying the officer Mr. Ahmed
[lie] too much. The officer say Mr. Ahmed to wait….As Mr. Ahmed arrival in the
emergency room he die. So Mr. Ahmed death is need to be investigated… we care
very much. Because that can happen to any one of us.”
Blum forwarded a copy to the Joint Intake Center of the Department of Homeland
Security where it became the subject of an internal document from the Department
of Homeland Security/ICE file dated September 26, 2005 which might never have
come to light if the ACLU had not obtained it through a Freedom of Information
Act (FOIA) Request in 2008 after an in-depth inquiry by the New York
Times.
The file reads: “Synopsis: On September 20, 2005, the Joint Intake Center
(JIC), Washington, D.C., received a packet of correspondence from Ms. Jean
Blum, President, American Liberty and Freedom for All (ALAFFA), Paterson, NJ.
According to the information received, Mr. Ahmed Tander, a Pakistani detainee
housed at the Monmouth County Correctional Institute, died on September 10,
2005, allegedly from a heart attack whose symptoms were obvious, severe and
ignored until it was too late.”
The death of Tanveer Ahmad (the correct spelling of his name) is of unusual
significance because the immigration
authorities could produce no record that Mr. Ahmad had ever been detained in
the first place, let alone that he had died in their custody. Without the
intervention of Jean Blum, this incident might never have come to light. Tom
Jawetz of the ACLU reflected on the troubling aspects of this particular case:
“We still do not know and we cannot know if there are other deaths that have
never been disclosed by ICE or that ICE itself knows nothing about.”
Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren pleading the necessity for greater accountability to
Congress wondered if failure to report this death reflected carelessness or
“something more sinister.”
Said the Times (April 3, 2009): “The difficulty of confirming
[Tanveer] Ahmad’s very existence showed that death could fall between the
cracks in immigration detention, the hundreds of county jails, for-profit
prisons and federal detention centers where more than 400,000 people a year are
held while the government tries to deport them.”
Although deaths in detention were
fairly frequent, prior to 2007, the only documentation available was a list
cobbled together by relatives of the deceased or their advocates. As recently
as 2007, it included only some 20 names. Through a FOIA request ICE eventually
disclosed 62 detention deaths since 2004 but declined to provide names, dates,
locations or causes until compelled to do so. By May 5, 2008, the list included
66 names. And by April 3, 2009 it stood at 92. The publication of an article
listing the deaths of two more detainees, previously unreported, brought the
list to 94. A sudden increase of ten
more, as reported by the New York Times on August 8, 2009 brought the master
list to 104 and then 106, where it stands today.
An examination of the statistical information for 2005 at Passaic County Jail
lists 75 suicide attempts in that year
alone, and one “successful” suicide —number 35 on the ICE master list—
which also includes one death “of natural causes,” seven deaths by hanging, 6 cases of asphyxia, 1 death by
drowning, (both the latter findings raise a number of questions), and,
interestingly, one cause of death, (in Corrections Corporation of America’s
Elizabeth facility) that of Boubacar Bah, which was initially listed as “brain
hemorrhage, fractured skull” and is now listed as “undetermined.” One death is
attributed to electrocution. According to a New York Times
article dated May 5, 2008, the detainee, Mr. Cesar Gonzalez-Baeza, was
operating a jackhammer that hit a power line. Such an unusual cause of death
raises an interesting question: what was an immigrant detainee doing operating
a jackhammer?
Detainee Gonzalez-Baeza’s death (and Ruth Jean-Baptiste’s accident while
washing floors cited earlier) may have been related to the decades-old practice
of leasing out cheap prison labor in
American jails and detention centers to private corporations. There have
been attempts by Congress—such as the Hawes Cooper Act (effective 1934) and the
Ashurst-Sumner Act, (1935) which tried to eliminate prison-plantations and
‘factories with fences’; but by 1990, with their repeal, it became permissible
for prisoners to produce products entering the stream of interstate commerce.
According to Andrew Bosworth, an assistant professor of Government at the
University of Texas at Brownsville, “many of the largest corporations in
America have exploited prison labor in what might be called ‘Operation
Sweatshop.’ Starbucks, Microsoft,
Boeing, Victoria’s Secret and other companies have participated in prison
labor programs.”